Executive Summary:
- On January 4, 2022, the Federal Executive sent to the Permanent Commission the list of three people for the appointment of the President Commissioner of the Energy Regulatory Commission (“CRE”).
- The Law on Coordinated Regulatory Bodies in Energy Matters states that the President Commissioner of the CRE must be appointed from among the shortlist that the Federal Executive presents to the Senate and will serve as such for a period of seven years, concluding his/her term on December 31, 2029.
- The Federal Executive presented the list of three candidates for President Commissioner of the CRE: Alfonso López Alvarado, Leopoldo Vicente Melchi García and Victor David Palacios Gutiérrez.
On January 4, 2022, the President of the Republic, through the Ministry of the Interior (the "Federal Executive"), sent to the Permanent Commission1 the shortlist of three people for the appointment of the President Commissioner of the Energy Regulatory Commission (“CRE”).
The President Commissioner of the CRE would be approved and appointed by the Senate of the Republic once the three candidates submitted for consideration for the position by the Federal Executive appear.
The Law on Coordinated Regulatory Bodies in Energy Matters states that the President Commissioner of the CRE must be appointed from among the shortlist that the Federal Executive presents to the Senate and will serve as such for a period of seven years, concluding his/her term on December 31, 2029.
For its part, Section VII of Article 78 of the Political Constitution of the United Mexican States states that, during the recesses of the Congress of the Union2, the Permanent Commission will ratify the appointments made by the Federal Executive of the members of the CRE.
In compliance with these precepts, and derived from the vacancy generated in the governing body of the CRE due to the expiration of the term of Leopoldo Vicente Melchi García as President Commissioner of the CRE, the Federal Executive saw fit to present the list with the following three candidates for President Commissioner of the CRE3: Alfonso Lopez Alvarado, Leopoldo Vicente Melchi Garcia and Victor David Palacios Gutierrez.
- Alfonso Lopez Alvarado
He is a Chemical Engineer from the Michoacana University of San Nicolás de Hidalgo, with a Master's Degree in Petrochemical and Refining Process Engineering from the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (“UNAM”) and a Master in Business Administration from the Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de MéxicoSince 2019, he has been the General Director of Petroleum Contracts at the Ministry of Energy (“SENER”).
- Leopoldo Vicente Melchi Garcia
He is a Chemical Engineer from the Universidad Veracruzana, with diplomas in Administration from the Pan-American Institute of Senior Business Management, in Environmental Policy Instruments and Environmental Protection from the Universidad Autónoma Metropolitana and in Efficient Use of Water and Quality Control from UNAM.
He served as President Commissioner of the CRE since 2019 and concluded his term as such on December 31, 2022. During his tenure as president of the CRE, Melchi has worked closely with SENER, and the process of issuing new permits to private participants in the oil and electricity sectors has been paused.
- Victor David Palacios Gutierrez
He holds a degree in Chemical Engineering from the Autonomous University of Puebla. Since 2022, he has been General Director of Natural Gas and Petrochemicals at SENER.
The importance of having the appointment of the President Commissioner of the CRE lies in the fact that he/she has specific powers, such as coordinating the work of the CRE in its capacity as the Coordinated Regulatory Body in Energy Matters; convening the sessions of the Governing Body; representing the Coordinated Regulatory Body in Energy Matters before government agencies, institutions, individuals and corporations, national and foreign, as well as acting as its legal representative; providing for the execution of the resolutions and agreements of the Governing Body; among others.
A relevant fact about the proposed candidacies is the fact that Alfonso López Alvarado and Víctor David Palacios Gutiérrez were candidates to occupy a position as CRE Commissioner in 2020, but they did not obtain enough votes from the Senate to be appointed.
Given the above, it can be expected that Leopoldo Vicente Melchi García will repeat in office to give continuity to the public energy policy of the current administration, strengthening the productive companies of the State to the detriment of private participation in the energy sector.
In addition, and based on the profiles of the candidates, it is considered that the CRE will continue with a trend focused on strengthening the hydrocarbon sector, particularly the oil sector, since none of the candidates has significant experience in the electrical sector.
The candidates will be summoned to appear before the Legislature to determine their suitability to fill the position, and in the event that the candidates are not chosen from among these three candidates, because the majority of two thirds of the members present in the Assembly is not reached, the Federal Executive will send a new list of three candidates for consideration. If this is also rejected, the President of the Republic may directly appoint the President Commissioner of the CRE.
Finally, in relation to the election of CRE Commissioners, it should be noted that the CRE has an additional vacancy as commissioner, since Luis Guillermo Pineda Bernal ended his term on December 31, 2022.
1 The Permanent Commission is composed of 37 legislators, of which 19 are deputies and 18 are senators.
2 The Senate has been in recess since December 15, 2022, and will resume activities on January 31, 2023.
3 Arranged in strict alphabetical order based on their first surname.