Outright nullity or nullity for specific purposes? In auditing, the answer can change the outcome of the trial.
The Regional Plenary Sessions resolved a conflict of criteria between Collegiate Courts. The issue was what happens when the act by which the auditing authority delegates to other officials the power to disclose the facts or omissions detected in an audit does not properly establish its competence.
One court saw it as a formal defect, leading to a nullity for all purposes, while the other treated it as incompetence and annulled it outright.
The first criterion prevailed, so this sets a precedent that the lack or improper justification of competence in that act of delegation is a formal irregularity, which causes the corresponding act to be revoked so that another one is issued in which the authority correctly identifies the articles that allow it to delegate its powers.
Why does it matter?
With outright annulment, the resolution disappears completely; however, with annulment for specific purposes, the authority can correct the defect and reissue the act, which means that the tax contingency is not eliminated.
This point becomes especially relevant considering that the passage of time increases this contingency as updates and surcharges continue to be generated, which could even be counterproductive for the individual.
It is important to consider that the jurisprudence only refers to the delegation of powers, not to whether the person has the power to issue the act itself, these being different assumptions that, if applicable, must be argued separately.



